This somewhat convoluted script by Rick Elice based on the novel by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson is an adventure story, mystery and juggling act. Two ships with two mysteriously switched trunks and a father and daughter on separate vessels, make their way to Rundoon Island. Adventuring daughter meets orphan boys — pirates and mayhem ensue and the magic of “star stuff” is demonstrated in many ways.
Director/choreographer Brian Farnham has become a master-juggler, in service of this script, with the help of a lively cast/crew flipping crates and ropes and more, flying and tossing folks overboard in artistic and dramatic ways — aided by a razzle dazzle of lighting effects from designer/programmer James Brunk. Music director Angie Schwab led a small but excellent combo with keyboard, piano and percussion. Elisha Smith’s scenography was lovely. Costumes (Amanda Macomber) were wild and wonderful (especially the fabulous tie-patchwork robe) and Kayla Henry produced magical makeup and hair. (Black Stache’s mustache was Joe Dickson's own creation, however — and he also designed the appropriately scary sound.)
Yes, Joe Dickson was allowed to escape the tech world and let his Actor Flag fly as the hilarious villain wannabe Black Stache, destined for fame as Captain Hook. His swishing and swashing and deliciously snide comments were a treat, enhanced by the silly devotion and helpful corrections of his right hand man, Smee, wonderfully played by Jillian Stauffer.
Matthew Weisner was a tall but boyish “no name” orphan destined to become Peter Pan, abetted by his very cute fellow orphans, Daniel Beaver and Lyla Pople. Brave Molly Aster was beautifully played by Ava Taube, a bit too independent for her noble Starcatcher dad, Lord Aster, played with a dash of fatherly frustration by Frank Boston. Molly’s delightful attendant/nurse Mrs. Bumbrake was charmingly played by the tall but demure Luka Pawsek, romanced by the ruffian pirate Alf (Joe Clark).
Anthony Mandalari was powerful as pirate Bill Slank, and Lainie Plunkett scared us a bit, too, as the Fighting Prawn leading her mollusk army. Sara Lehman was particularly graceful as all manner of animals and mermaid “Teacher”. The ensemble was amazing, performing dancing/lifting/special effects, pirate-ing and the rest. The mermaid scene that opens the second act is a highlight!
This show is “family friendly” but a bit complicated for young children, and lasts a full two and a half hours, (including intermission, which may stretch kids’ attention spans, and many of the fun jokes and references could be lost on the youngsters. Still — a load of fun for most, with impressive effects and pace.
Peter and the Starcatcher continues through May 14, Thur-Sun - reserved tickets at http://riverwalktheatre.com or call 517-482-5700.